Book Club: Discussing ‘Above All Things’

Above All ThingsOur latest book is Above All Things, by Tanis Rideout. Book Club hostess Jacqueline Steward, who blogs at Best and Beyond, starts us off on the discussion below. Read what she thought about the book and join in.

Taking part in the BritMums Book Club with Penguin is a great way to score a free copy of new books, read along with a group of fellow bloggers and discuss what you loved (or hated) about them in the comfort of your own home.

Keep up to date with the latest by joining the BritMums Book Club community group and to be first to know about the next book and how to get your free copy!

What we thought of the book

“The English love rather to live well than live long”  —Arnold Lunn (tribute to Sandy Irvine and George Mallory)

Reading Tanis Rideout’s novel about Ruth and George Mallory and the ill-fated third attempt on Mt Everest was like reading three stories in one. Domestic life laid bare and the agonising wait for her beloved, handsome husband by his intelligent wife, Ruth. The journey and struggle to conquer Everest by the ill-fated team AND the politics and pressure placed on the expedition by the UK public and government to succeed. I felt like I was reading an inspiration for The Hunger Games. They didn’t appear to have much choice in their collective fate.

Mallory was  a man of a certain time and Rideout’s beautiful prose captures it perfectly. Handsome, witty, intelligent, empathetic, loving and selfish. He was clearly someone everyone would want to know. Above All Things captured my imagination and I have since been Googling George, Ruth, and  his young climbing companion, Sandy Irvine. It made me want to know more about their lives, the time it was set and of course the expedition.

What makes someone a hero?

What makes a hero? A difficult question.

My children wanted to know why/how he could leave his children? I wanted to know why they wore such unsubstantial clothes/kit to climb what was already known as a really treacherous expedition. I loved knowing that Burberry supplied the climbing clothes. It was also a great family game discussing his contemporaries now and who attracted a similar amount of media attention: David’s Beckham or Walliams anyone?

Life is tricky but knowing that split second decisions could make the difference between survival and success or death made me look at the nature of their responsibilities, expedition and exploring in a whole new light. The book is beautifully written and researched, particularly the chapters concentrating on Everest. Rideout’s obsession with Mallory and this time was clear from start to finish. I often feel shortchanged with novels as the author grows distracted and loses interest with their subject/writing, not with Above All Things.

Tell us what you thought about the book

What did you think? Did you find the different narratives helpful? Was Ruth sympathetic? Did you find the pressure she faced unbearable?

I’ve since Googled the key team behind the expedition and was surprised by Mallory’s full life before the expedition. Although relatively young when he died, he managed to pack a lot in. Find @Tanisrideout and you will find some fabulous archive images on her Twitter feed marking the 90th anniversary of the expedition (week of 2/5/14).
Look forward to reading and commenting on your thoughts/reviews so please add your link and I will come find you.

Sign up for the next book

The next title for our BritMums Book Club with Penguin will be announced soon and we will let you know via the group and announce on Twitter and G+ the next book. You’ll be the first to know about the next book and how to get your free copy!

Add you review link!

Share Button


BritMums is the UK’s original collective of lifestyle bloggers and digital influencers, fueling the country’s most influential social content. We lead the online conversation with members who are parent social influencers creating content on topics ranging from food, parenting, travel, politics, style and more.


  1. 19 May 2014 / 13:31

    Here’s my link –

    I really enjoyed the book despite it being totally different from what I’d normally read – I think it was a difficult book to read and left me feeling a bit emotionally battered but I am so glad I was able to read something like this and historical fiction is something I’ll definitely consider again in the future